experience can make all the difference
We have over 75 years of combined experience
expect personalized attention and care
We are with you every step of the way on your road to recovery
an AWARD-WINNING law firm
We were voted best law firm on Long Island in 2024
100% PLAINTIFF FOCUSED — NEVER INSURANCE COMPANIES
We fight exclusively for injured people, delivering real results for members of our community.
Understanding New York’s No-Fault Insurance System
After a motor vehicle accident on Long Island, most people assume the next legal issue is determining who was at fault. While fault is important in accident cases, the first legal system you encounter in New York is something called No-Fault insurance.
New York’s No-Fault law is designed to ensure that injured individuals receive quick access to medical treatment and wage replacement without waiting for a lawsuit. Instead of immediately pursuing the at-fault driver, it is your own automobile insurance policy becomes responsible for paying certain benefits regardless of fault.
This system applies whether you were a driver on the Long Island Expressway, a passenger in a car on the Northern State Parkway or on a bicycle on the shoulder of Sunrise Highway, or a pedestrian crossing Jericho Turnpike. It applies to drivers, passengers, pedestrians, and cyclists struck by vehicles.
In theory, No-Fault provides stability. In practice, it is heavily regulated, procedural, and often manipulated by insurance carriers.
You will receive multiple forms and communications within days of notifying your carrier of the crash. You will be asked to verify employment if you make a lost wage claim. You may be scheduled for Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs) if you are seeing doctors. If treatment continues beyond a short period, scrutiny often increases.
Understanding how this system works, and how insurance companies apply it in real-world claims, is critical to protecting your medical care, income and legal rights.
What Is No-Fault Insurance in New York?
New York requires every registered vehicle to carry N0-Fault insurance, also known as Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage. This mandatory coverage applies to:
- Drivers
- Passengers
- Pedestrians struck by vehicles
- Cyclists injured by motor vehicles
Basic No-Fault provides up to $50,000 in “basic economic loss” per person.
Economic loss includes:
- Payment of medical treatment
- 80% of lost wages, up to $2,000 per month
- Transportation expenses to medical appointments
- Up to $25 per day for certain household services
- Funeral expenses in fatal cases
Some drivers carry optional additional PIP (APIP) coverage, which increases available benefits beyond the $50,000 statutory minimum. In serious accidents involving surgery, extended physical therapy, neurological treatment, or prolonged disability, these additional coverages can be very important.
Unlike a bodily injury lawsuit, No-Fault benefits are paid regardless of fault. Even if another driver was clearly negligent, your own insurance policy is typically the first source of payment for medical bills and lost wages.
However, No-Fault is limited to economic losses. It does not compensate for pain and suffering, emotional distress, or diminished quality of life. Those damages are only available if your injuries through a claim against the at fault driver’s insurance carrier.
“I focus 100% of my practice on Personal Injury. I believe this area of law takes ALL of an attorney’s focus to be well versed.”
- Steven Palermo
The 30-Day Application Deadline
One of the most critical aspects of any No-Fault claim is the 30-day rule.
The injured person must file an application for No-Fault benefits within 30 days of the accident.
Failing to file within this window can result in denial unless there is a legally acceptable excuse.
Many people assume their insurance company will automatically process everything after you notify them of an accident. That assumption can be dangerous. An application must be filed.
Prompt filing protects your eligibility for medical and wage benefits.
verdicts & settlements
$5.5
million
For injuries caused by the mistaken release of a prison convict
$3.2
million
For a client who was injured after getting hit by a truck
$1.7
million
For a client who was injured from a construction accident
$1.5
million
For a client injured in a motor vehicle accident
$1.05
million
The victim suffered a fractured ankle while on another parties premises
$1.025
million
For a client who was injured from a drunk driver
$975
thousand
For a client injured in a motor vehicle accident
$950
thousand
For a client injured in a motor vehicle accident
Meet Steven Palermo, Personal Injury Lawyer
Across Long Island
I’m Steven Palermo, a Long Island personal injury lawyer with nearly three decades of experience representing people whose lives have been changed by serious accidents. I built my practice on honesty, personal attention, and a willingness to take on powerful insurance companies and corporations when they refuse to do what’s right.
My commitment to personal injury law comes from being in your shoes. In college, I suffered an injury that required a six-hour knee surgery and ended my college lacrosse career, with a recovery that took years. Several years later, I was in a severe accident when my car was rear-ended by a box truck and pushed into oncoming traffic. I lived through the pain, the uncertainty, and the frustration of dealing with insurance companies that questioned my injuries and tried to shift blame instead of taking responsibility. Experiencing that process firsthand showed me how unfair it can be for injured people who are just trying to recover and move forward.
Today, I’ve represented hundreds of injured clients across Long Island and recovered more than $75 million on their behalf. I approach every case knowing there is a real person behind it, someone dealing with pain, stress, and uncertainty, because I’ve been there myself.
“...knowledgeable and easy to work with.”
Steven Palermo was extremely professional and got me a settlement when I wasn’t even sure I had a case. His staff was very knowledgeable and easy to work with. Will definitely use them again if the need arises.
Sherri M.
google review
“My experience with this law firm was excellent.”
Steven Palermo went above and beyond his call of duty to make sure I was awarded all that I was entitled to. Mr Palermo’s staff was very professional and kind in such a tender time in my life. I highly recommend Mr. Palermo along with this law firm to all my friends and relatives. In fact I already have.
Gillean G.
google review
“...cannot be happier with our decision!”
Steven Palermo was referred to us from a friend and I cannot be happier with our decision. He worked hard to obtain a settlement to compensate for pain I had to undergo as a result of an accident. I will continue to refer anyone in need of a car accident attorney to this office! Thanks Palermo for everything!
James M.
google review
“All my expectations were met...”
Steve and his staff were very polite and diligent. I felt the human side of the business. They even came to my home to visit. Steven always told me the truth about my case. All my expectations were met, and I truly appreciate that!
Astrid C.
google review
online ratings
helping all of Long Island
click here toView All Practice AreasA Passion For Helping Injured People
Reviewing Your Insurance Policy and Declaration Page
One of the first steps we take when handling a No-Fault claim is reviewing your automobile insurance policy, specifically your Declarations Page, often referred to as the “Dec Page.”
The Declarations Page is a summary sheet issued by your insurance carrier. It outlines:
- Your No-Fault (PIP) limits
• Whether you carry Additional PIP (APIP)
• Optional Basic Economic Loss (OBEL) coverage
• Bodily injury liability limits
• Uninsured/Supplemental Underinsured Motorist (UM/SUM) coverage
• Policy period and insured vehicles
Many clients are unaware that they carry enhanced PIP coverage until we review the policy. Additional PIP or OBEL coverage can significantly increase available benefits beyond the basic $50,000 limit. In serious injury cases, that difference can determine whether medical treatment remains fully covered.
We also confirm whether there are multiple applicable policies. In certain situations, coverage priority may depend on:
- Whether you were the driver or passenger
• Whether the vehicle was owned or borrowed
• Whether a household member’s policy applies
• Whether commercial or rideshare policies are involved
Priority of coverage issues can become complex, particularly in multi-vehicle collisions or when pedestrians are injured.
This review allows us to plan strategically — not just for immediate medical bills, but for the full length of your claim.
Understanding Additional Coverages on Your Policy
In addition to basic PIP, some policies include:
Additional Personal Injury Protection (APIP) – increases available medical and wage benefits.
Optional Basic Economic Loss (OBEL) – provides extended wage or medical coverage.
Supplementary Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (SUM/UM) – applies if the at-fault driver lacks enough insurance to cover your injury claim.
While No-Fault covers economic losses, SUM/UM coverage may later become critical if you have serious injuries and the responsible driver lacks adequate liability limits.
Many injured individuals do not know what coverage they purchased. Insurance agents often add or omit optional coverages without full explanation.
A careful review of your Declarations Page ensures no available coverage is overlooked.
Regulatory Framework and Insurance Company Oversight
The entire No-Fault system is governed by regulations enforced by the New York State Department of Financial Services.
These regulations dictate:
- When applications must be filed
• How medical bills must be submitted
• How insurers can request verification
• When Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs) can be scheduled
• How arbitration proceedings are conducted
• When benefits may be lawfully terminated
While the system is intended to provide quick access to care, insurance carriers are permitted to investigate and challenge claims. That oversight frequently becomes a source of abuse.
Insurers have internal review departments that examine billing patterns, treatment duration, and disability claims. Repeated verification requests, IMEs, and peer reviews are common in cases.
Understanding not only what the law requires, but how insurance companies apply it in practice, is critical to protecting your benefits.
You have questions? We have answers.
No legal mumbo jumbo—just easy-to-read answers to the questions that matter most. Our guide to handling New York State car accidents is written just for you.
download the “e-book”
Medical Billing and Treatment Oversight
Once the application is filed, medical providers submit bills directly to the No-Fault carrier.
Insurers review these bills for:
- Medical necessity
• Proper coding
• Timely submission
• Causation
If a provider fails to respond to verification requests properly, payment can be denied.
Patients are often unaware of billing disputes occurring behind the scenes. Yet those disputes can interrupt treatment.
Wage Loss Benefits in Detail
No-Fault wage loss benefits are often misunderstood.
The system generally pays 80% of lost earnings, subject to a $2,000 monthly cap under basic coverage. This is often inadequate for higher salary people
Also, for hourly and salaried employees, calculation may be straightforward.
But for self-employed individuals, commission-based earners, contractors, or seasonal workers, documentation becomes more complex.
Insurance carriers may request:
- Employer verification forms
- Tax returns
- 1099 forms
- Pay stubs
- Business records
- Disability certifications
Inconsistent disability notes can result in denial of wage claims.
We assist in organizing documentation and ensuring that disability certifications align with wage loss submissions.
Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs)
IMEs are one of the most significant turning points in a No-Fault claim.
Insurance companies are permitted to require injured individuals to attend medical examinations with physicians they select.
Despite being labeled “independent,” these physicians are retained and paid by the insurer. They also receive significant repeat business from insurance carriers
IME reports often conclude:
- Treatment is no longer necessary
• Disability has resolved
• Injuries are unrelated to the accident
Even when a person’s treating physicians disagree, IME denials will trigger termination of benefits.
If you fail to attend a scheduled IME — even due to miscommunication — benefits may be terminated automatically and you could get stuck with the bills.
We treat IMEs as important events.
We:
- Confirm proper notice was given
- Prepare clients for the examination
- Review the IME report carefully
- Challenge unsupported findings
Repeated IMEs may be scheduled in long-term treatment cases. These examinations can be used strategically by insurers to apply pressure.
Effective preparation and prompt response are critical to protecting ongoing benefits.
Common Tactics Used to Deny No-Fault Claims
Insurance carriers frequently rely on predictable denial patterns.
Common tactics include:
- Alleging failure to attend IMEs
- Claiming treatment is excessive
- Arguing that injuries are degenerative or pre-existing
- Asserting gaps in treatment
- Disputing wage documentation
- Sending repeated verification requests
Gaps in treatment are particularly scrutinized. If therapy stops for weeks, insurers may argue that the injury resolved.
Similarly, prior injuries may be used to dispute causation.
Proper documentation and consistency in treatment records help counter these arguments.
Arbitration: How No-Fault Disputes Are Resolved
When benefits are denied, disputes typically proceed to arbitration.
Arbitration under No-Fault regulations is largely document-driven.
Evidence includes:
- Medical records
• IME reports
• Billing submissions
• Disability certifications
• Legal arguments
An arbitrator issues a written decision. Appeals may proceed to a master arbitrator and potentially court review.
Although arbitration is intended to be efficient, preparation significantly impacts outcome.
For further information on No-Fault claims visit New York State Department of Financial Services.
When Do You Need a Lawyer?
Some minor No-Fault claims resolve without issue.
However, legal representation becomes increasingly important when injuries are serious or prolonged.
Under New York law, serious injury includes:
- Fractures
• Significant disfigurement
• Permanent loss of use
• Permanent consequential limitation
• Significant limitation
• The 90/180-day rule
The 90/180 category applies when injuries prevent you from performing substantially all usual activities for at least 90 of the first 180 days after the accident.
These categories require objective medical evidence.
Insurance companies frequently challenge whether limitations are significant or permanent.
When injuries qualify, your case transitions beyond No-Fault.
To pursue claims for pain and suffering you may want to retain Long Island personal injury representation. Protecting your rights for liability claims requires careful preparation and documentation from the beginning.
Serving Nassau and Suffolk Counties
We represent injured individuals throughout Long Island.
If your accident occurred in Nassau County and would like more specific county related information, visit our Nassau County No-Fault Insurance Attorney page.
If your accident occurred in Suffolk County and would like more specific county related information, visit our Suffolk No-Fault Insurance Claims Attorney page.
Free Consultation
If you have questions about No-Fault benefits, lost wages, Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs), or denied claims, contact Palermo Law for a free consultation. We proudly represent injured individuals across Long Island from our conveniently located offices in Babylon, Carle Place, East Hampton, Elmont, Hauppauge, Huntington, Mineola, Patchogue and Riverhead.
legal memberships & awards
