se habla español

Suffolk (631) 621-6183

Nassau (516) 240-9904

Menu

Case Study | Liquor Liability

$450,000 Bar Fight Assault

Client assaulted in a bar by a patron who was over-served alcohol by the establishment.

Amount Recovered $450,000
Resolution Settlement Prior to Trial
Venue Suffolk County Supreme Court

What Happened

Our client was a regular patron at a local Suffolk County bar. On the night in question, two other patrons began fighting. A third patron, highly intoxicated, mistakenly believed our client was involved in the altercation and assaulted him without provocation, fracturing his ankle. Our client was an innocent bystander wrongly targeted due to the assailant’s intoxicated state.

How We Won

Through witness testimony we established that the assailant and both other patrons involved in the initial altercation were all highly intoxicated, demonstrating a clear pattern of alcohol over-service by the bar’s staff. The assailant lacked the financial means to satisfy a judgment. Faced with overwhelming evidence of negligent service, the bar’s insurance carrier agreed to pay the full amount of damages.

Key Legal Theory

Dram Shop liability under GOL § 11-101. Pattern of alcohol over-service proven through witness testimony establishing all three involved patrons were visibly and severely intoxicated at the time of the assault.

All Case Results

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Every case is different, and the results obtained in this matter depended on the specific facts and circumstances involved. This case study is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Take the next step

Have You Suffered a Serious Injury?

When you’re ready to talk, we’re here. We offer a free, no obligation consultation at any of our 9 offices across Long Island, and we’re happy to come to you if you’re unable to travel. We have been fighting for Long Island families for over  25 years.

We’ll give you our honest assessment and tell you exactly how we’d approach your case. Our record speaks for itself. Our team has never represented an insurance company and never will. When you call Palermo Law, you’ll know quickly why so many Long Island families have trusted us since 1994.

Get Started Today