Long Island New York
A police accident report can significantly influence your Long Island car accident claim, but what happens if it's inaccurate or places you at fault? Learn how insurance companies use these reports, whether errors can be corrected, and why an unfavorable report doesn't necessarily mean you don't have a case.
If you’ve been involved in a car accident on Long Island, one of the first things an insurance company will probably want to see is the police accident report. That report can have a significant impact on how your claim is handled, particularly when there is a disagreement over who caused the accident.
Over the years, I’ve reviewed thousands of police accident reports involving crashes throughout Suffolk and Nassau Counties. Some clearly support my client’s version of what happened. Others are less favorable. And some, quite frankly, are wrong.
One of the most common questions I hear is whether an unfavorable police report means they don’t have a case. The short answer is no. A favorable report can make your claim go more smoothly, but an unfavorable one doesn’t mean you should give up.
A police accident report is an official record prepared by a responding officer following a motor vehicle accident. In New York, it is generally prepared on a standardized form known as the MV-104A. It may include:
When and where the collision occurred.
Driver, owner, vehicle, and insurance details for those involved.
Accounts given by drivers and witnesses at the scene.
Vehicle damage, road surface, and weather conditions.
The officer’s drawing and written description of the accident.
Conduct or circumstances the officer believes contributed to the crash.
Injuries, emergency response, and any tickets issued.
For someone pursuing a Long Island car accident claim, this information can be extremely valuable.
I strongly recommend calling the police after a collision, particularly if anyone is injured or there is a disagreement about how it happened.
People are generally more likely to give an accurate account immediately after an accident, especially when speaking with a police officer. I’ve seen drivers admit at the scene that they weren’t paying attention or failed to see another vehicle, only to give a different version later.
Police response also provides an opportunity to document vehicle damage, debris and roadway conditions before the scene changes. Not everyone tells the truth, of course, and honest people can be mistaken after a frightening event.
If you’re injured, medical care comes first. Don’t delay treatment to speak with an officer. Certain crashes also require the driver to file a report with the DMV within ten days, even if police responded.
See the New York DMV accident report form for the driver-reporting requirements.
One of the first sections I review is the contributing factors section. Here, the investigating officer identifies conduct or circumstances believed to have contributed to the collision, such as driver inattention, failure to yield, following too closely, unsafe speed or disregarding a traffic signal.
Suppose my client drives through an intersection with a green light and another vehicle turns left across their path. If the officer identifies failure to yield by the turning driver, that finding can help persuade an insurer to accept liability. But contributing factors are the officer’s assessment, not a binding legal determination of fault.
In my experience, insurers give these reports considerable weight. A favorable report can eliminate a prolonged argument over liability and let us focus on the client’s injuries, medical treatment, lost earnings and damages. An unfavorable report can lead an adjuster to deny responsibility or allege comparative fault, even when the officer’s assessment is questionable.
A favorable report can eliminate a prolonged argument over liability and let us focus on the client’s injuries, medical treatment, lost earnings, and damages.
An unfavorable report can lead an adjuster to deny responsibility or allege comparative fault — but it doesn’t mean you should give up. Fault is determined by the facts and the law, not the police report alone.
Denied over a police report?
If you were injured in a crash in Suffolk or Nassau County and an insurer is leaning on an unfavorable report, we can examine whether it matches the actual evidence and challenge it. Review your options before giving up.
Absolutely not. Most officers make a genuine effort to document the scene, but they usually arrive after the collision. They may rely on conflicting driver statements, incomplete witness accounts or physical evidence that doesn’t tell the whole story.
I’ve reviewed plenty of reports where I disagreed with the conclusion. I never evaluate a case based solely on the report. I look at photographs, damage, witness statements, traffic laws, video and, when appropriate, accident reconstruction evidence.
You can try. Departments may correct names, insurance details or other factual mistakes. If the report attributes a statement to you that you never made, I would recommend asking the department to document the discrepancy.
For example, if the report says you admitted speeding but you did not, the department might add: “Driver appeared at headquarters on October 15 and stated that she did not tell the investigating officer she was speeding.” The original statement may remain, but the record will at least reflect your disagreement. That is better than leaving the error unchallenged.
Changing an officer’s opinion about fault is usually harder. Procedures vary by department, and a correction or supplement is not guaranteed.
I don’t simply accept that decision. I examine whether the report is consistent with the actual evidence, explain the discrepancies and present material supporting my client’s account. Sometimes the insurer reconsiders. Other times, we need to file suit.
Litigation allows us to question drivers under oath, obtain relevant records, seek video and examine witnesses. If a case has merit, the insurance company’s denial is not the last word. A judge or jury can reach a different conclusion.
Some portions may be admissible, but not everything in a report automatically comes into evidence. An officer’s own observations, such as vehicle locations and visible damage, may be admitted with a proper foundation. A party’s admission recorded by the officer may also be admissible when the applicable evidence requirements are satisfied.
An officer who did not witness the collision generally cannot establish fault simply by writing an opinion in the report. An officer who witnessed events or is properly qualified as an expert presents a different question. The rules also distinguish admissible statements from hearsay supplied by third parties.
New York courts discuss these limits in Yassin v. Blackman, 188 A.D.3d 62 (2d Dept. 2020).
The foundational decision Johnson v. Lutz, 253 N.Y. 124 (1930) likewise addresses statements supplied to officers by third parties.
An officer’s own observations, such as vehicle locations and visible damage, may be admitted with a proper foundation. A party’s admission recorded by the officer may also be admissible when the evidence requirements are met.
An officer who did not witness the collision generally cannot establish fault simply by writing an opinion in the report, and hearsay supplied by third parties is treated differently.
New York follows comparative negligence. You may still recover damages even if you were partly responsible, although your recovery generally will be reduced by your percentage of fault. For example, a $100,000 award reduced by 20% comparative fault becomes $80,000. The officer’s contributing-factor codes do not set those percentages.
In addition to liability, injured drivers should understand New York no-fault insurance benefits.
A favorable police accident report is always something I like to see. It can simplify the claims process and avoid unnecessary disputes. But I’ve handled enough cases to know that reports are not always accurate.
If you’ve been injured on Long Island, call the police, obtain medical care, get the report and review it carefully. If something is wrong, don’t ignore it. And if an insurer relies on an unfavorable report to deny your claim, speak with an attorney before giving up.
The police report may influence how your case begins, but it doesn’t have to determine how your case ends.
| 1 | Call the police
Especially if anyone is injured or there’s a disagreement about how the crash happened — it documents the scene before conditions change. |
| 2 | Get medical care first
If you’re injured, treatment comes first. Don’t delay care to speak with an officer. |
| 3 | File a DMV report if required
Certain crashes require the driver to file a report with the DMV within ten days, even if police responded. |
| 4 | Obtain and review the report
Get your copy and read it carefully — from the investigating agency or the New York State DMV. |
| 5 | Correct any errors
If something is wrong or a statement is misattributed to you, ask the department to correct it or document your disagreement. |
| 6 | Speak with an attorney before giving up
If an insurer relies on an unfavorable report to deny your claim, don’t treat that as the final word. |
Yes. A favorable police accident report can make it easier to establish liability with the insurance company. If the investigating officer identifies the other driver as contributing to the accident, the insurer may be more willing to accept responsibility. However, the officer’s conclusions are not legally binding and do not guarantee a successful claim.
Yes. An unfavorable police accident report does not automatically prevent you from recovering compensation. Police officers sometimes make mistakes or rely on incomplete information. Your attorney can challenge the officer’s conclusions using witness testimony, photographs, surveillance footage, and other evidence. Ultimately, fault is determined by the facts and applicable law, not the police report alone.
The contributing factors section identifies circumstances the investigating officer believes contributed to the collision. Examples include driver inattention, following too closely, failure to yield, and unsafe speed. Insurance companies frequently consider these findings when evaluating liability, but they represent the officer’s assessment rather than a final legal determination of fault.
You can request a correction or supplemental report from the police department that investigated the accident. Departments may correct factual errors or document your disagreement with a statement attributed to you. However, officers are generally less willing to change their opinions about fault. Each department has its own procedures for reviewing requested corrections.
Certain portions of a police accident report may be admissible if the proper legal foundation is established. An officer’s personal observations and qualifying party admissions may be admitted. However, an officer’s unsupported opinion about who caused an accident generally is not admissible when the officer did not witness the collision or qualify as an expert.
Tell the responding officer your version of what happened and identify any witnesses or physical evidence supporting your account. Take photographs if it is safe to do so. If the police report contains inaccurate information, request a correction or supplement. An attorney can also investigate the accident and challenge false statements during litigation.
Yes. Insurance companies may rely heavily on police accident reports when deciding whether to accept or deny liability. However, their decisions are not final legal determinations. If the report is inaccurate or incomplete, your attorney can present additional evidence, challenge the insurer’s position, and pursue a lawsuit when appropriate.
You can generally request a police accident report from the law enforcement agency that investigated the collision or through the New York State DMV. Availability and processing times vary. Reports may not be immediately accessible. Keep the accident date, location, and report number available to help locate the correct record.
You may still have a valid personal injury claim. New York follows comparative negligence rules, meaning your compensation can generally be reduced by your percentage of responsibility. A police officer’s identification of contributing factors does not establish those percentages. The evidence and applicable law determine how responsibility is ultimately allocated.
If you were injured and the police report incorrectly places responsibility on you, speaking with a personal injury attorney is a good idea. An attorney can evaluate the report, investigate conflicting evidence, and challenge an insurance company’s denial. An unfavorable police report can complicate your case, but it does not necessarily defeat it.
The information provided in this blog is for general informational purposes only and reflects the opinions of the author. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different, and results depend on the specific facts and applicable law. You should not act or rely on any information in this blog without first seeking advice from a qualified attorney regarding your individual situation.